While the Citi Simplicity card does have one of the longest introductory APRs for balance transfers available on the market, the high 5% balance transfer fee and lack of rewards lessen its value to consumers. Compared to other balance transfer cards, it falls short.
For example, the Discover it Balance Transfer card offers a 3% introductory balance transfer fee and offers 2% cash back at gas stations and restaurants each quarter, as well as 1% cash back on all other purchases. The card offers a 0% interest introductory period of 14 months, which is longer than the Citi Simplicity card’s intro offer. Plus, all cash back earned is matched at the end of the first year as a new cardholder bonus. Even with offering these rewards, the card boasts no annual fee. If a consumer wants to pay off their debt and then have a great cashback option to use going forward, the Discover it Balance Transfer card is a much better choice.
Additionally, the Chase Freedom card gives a whopping 5% cash back on select categories each month (up to $1,500, then 1%), 1% cash back on all other purchases and offers 0% APR on balance transfers for 15 months. If consumers transfer a balance within the first 60 days of the account opening, they’ll be rewarded with only a 3% balance transfer fee ($5 minimum); any balance transfers completed afterward will see the fee increase to 5% ($5 minimum). After the introductory period, the standard APR will apply.
Unlike the Citi Simplicity card and the Discover it Balance Transfer card, the Chase Freedom card offers a sign-up bonus of $150 after spending $500 on purchases within the first three months of the account opening. If you manage to pay off your balance transfer before then, and hit the spending requirement, you’ll be rewarded generously.
The Citi Simplicity card is a decent choice for consumers who only want to pay down debt without interest, won’t use the card for spending and don’t want the bells and whistles of a rewards card.